The Role of Visible Wealth for Deprivation

The Role of Visible Wealth for Deprivation

Journal Articles

Motivated by the lack of literature linking actual to perceived relative deprivation, this paper assesses the role of visibility in goods and assets vis-à-vis income behind perceptions of relative deprivation. We rely on household survey data that include unique information on reported perceived deprivation with a pre-specified reference group, namely others in the same town or village. Based on a large number of asset and consumption items, we create an index of visible wealth by aggregating visible goods and assets using principal component weights. We show that relative deprivation in visible wealth has a significantly stronger effect than income in determining levels of perceived relative deprivation. The finding is robust under various sensitivity checks and for a number of controls. Our result sheds light on the importance of the visibility of the objects of comparison on an individual’s assessment of the own relative economic situation and proposes that future research should not only rely on income-based deprivation measures.

Publication Overview

DOI Link (opens in a new tab)
Cit. Bertram-Hümmer, V., & Baliki, G. (2015). The Role of Visible Wealth for Deprivation. Social Indicators Research, 124(3), 765–783.

Continue Reading:

  • Transfer behavior in migrant sending communities

    Migration is likely to change established private transfer systems in poor countries. In rural Kyrgyzstan, households with migrants abroad help others with money. They receive labor assistance from others. This may be a sign of reciprocal, but asymmetric (money vs. labor) transfers. This is potentially good news for policymakers. … read more »

  • How marriages based on bride capture differ: Evidence from Kyrgyzstan

    A significant proportion of women in the Kyrgyz Republic marry via ala kachuu, generally translated as bride capture or kidnapping. Many regard this practice as harmless elopement or a tradition; others perceive it as a form of forced marriage. This paper contributes to the understanding of ala kachuu by exploring the extent to which couples in these marriages differ from those in arranged or love marriages. This paper provides a novel source of evidence on the possible nonconsensual nature of bride capture in Kyrgyzstan, adding further weight to those arguing that it is forced. … read more »